← All articles

The sampling revolution

When quotation took centre stage in music

The Winstons were a band from Washington, D.C. who reached number seven on the US chart in 1969 with the single Color Him Father: a gold record that July, and the Grammy for best rhythm and blues song the following year. They hold another title too, less famous and never rewarded: they made the most sampled piece of music in history.

The B-side of that single is Amen, Brother. One minute and twenty-six seconds in, the band drops out and the drummer, Gregory Coleman, plays four bars on his own: seven seconds. In 2019 I wrote that the fragment had been reused 3,300 times. The count kept by WhoSampled has not stopped since: it stood at 2,835 in March 2018, when Guinness World Records certified the record, and at 6,873 in July 2025.

Amen, Brother by The Winstons (1969). The break comes in at 1:26: four bars of drums and nothing else.

It is known as the Amen break, and if you think you have never heard it, you have. Slowed down, it went into hip hop: in 1988 it was inside N.W.A's Straight Outta Compton. Sped up and chopped to pieces, it became the backbone of jungle and drum and bass in the 1990s.

Building music out of fragments of other recordings is older than digital audio: in 1948 Pierre Schaeffer was already composing his musique concrète studies in Paris by recombining noises cut onto disc. But it was the digital sampler, once it became affordable in the second half of the 1980s, that blew the possibilities open.

Technically, sampling happens every time you record digitally: the analogue-to-digital converter measures the electrical signal thousands of times a second and writes it down as a string of 0s and 1s. A recording made that way does not wear out, can be copied endlessly and, above all, can be cut and reshaped inside a DAW until it turns into a different composition.

So when does a piece of somebody else's record become a question of rights? That is where the modern definition comes from, more legal than artistic:

"The use and reproduction, in a new recording, of a portion of pre-existing musical material that is owned or controlled by any person or entity other than the user of the sample" (Il diritto della musica, P. Visco and S. Galli, an Italian handbook of music law; my translation).

It is delicate ground, judged case by case, because two sets of rights are in play: copyright in what was written, and the related rights in what was recorded.

Hip hop grew up inside all this. It was born in the Bronx in the early 1970s (in 2019 I wrote the 1980s, a decade late), when DJs like Kool Herc put two copies of the same record on the decks to keep the break going round while the MCs talked over it. Rapper's Delight by the Sugarhill Gang, September 1979, the first rap record to enter the US Top 40, rests entirely on the bass line of Chic's Good Times. Back then I called it a loop, and it is not: the bass was replayed in the studio by a band. That did not keep the lawyers away. Nile Rodgers and Bernard Edwards threatened to sue, and have been credited as writers ever since.

Rapper's Delight (1979): the bass line of Chic's Good Times, replayed in the studio rather than sampled.

Over time the quotation became less explicit, sometimes hidden. Miley Cyrus's We Can't Stop (2013) quotes a line from La Di Da Di in its chorus, the 1985 track by Doug E. Fresh and Slick Rick made of nothing but voice and beatbox and borrowed by artists of every kind: both are listed among the writers. Portishead went full circle. They recorded their own music, had it cut to vinyl, threw the records on the studio floor, walked all over them and only then sampled them (an expensive way to get hold of a second-hand record).

What happened next

Nobody, meanwhile, has ever paid a penny in royalties for the Winstons' break. Coleman died homeless in 2006. In 2015 Richard Spencer, the band's leader, received the proceeds of an online collection started in England, more than £18,000: a thank-you, not a fee. He died in 2020.

In Europe, two seconds of music kept the courts busy for more than twenty years. In 1997 the producer Moses Pelham looped two seconds of Kraftwerk's Metall auf Metall (1977) in a track for Sabrina Setlur. In July 2019 the Court of Justice of the European Union ruled that even a very short sample needs the producer's permission, unless it has been altered to the point of being unrecognisable to the ear. On 14 April 2026 it added that a sample can fall under the pastiche exception, but only if the new track sets up a recognisable artistic dialogue with the original. Simply repeating it does not count.

A Brief History of Sampling, a video mash-up by Eclectic Method: a history of sampling made of nothing but samples.

Those who, like Mark Ronson, put sampling on the same level as original creation may be overstating it. But like quotations in literature, samples are now part of how music gets made.

What remains is seven seconds of drums from 1969, which made a fortune for almost everyone except the man who played them.

This piece is a revision of an article from September 2019. The Amen break count was updated; four points were corrected (the Winstons' award, which was for the single and not the album, the decade hip hop was born in, the "loop" in Rapper's Delight and the year of La Di Da Di); the story of the people who played that break and the two European rulings in the Kraftwerk case were added.

Alessandro Porri

More of these, here.

All articles →